• HOME
  • ABOUT
  • REVIEWS
  • CONTACT
  • FORUM

  • Flat Earth Exchange


    Rating:
    5
    Image of The Flat Earth/Exchange VOL 01 (Flat Earth Exchange)
    Author / Artist: 
    Toshimi Nigoshi
    Publisher: 
    CMX
    Volumes: 
    4 (complete)

    In a world where humans and androids co-exist, the human population is rapidly declining. As part of a plan to help preserve the species, High School student Kotaro Shiga is placed into a state of suspended animation. Waking up a century later, he finds a very changed world where androids are in charge and humans are very scarce. The Androids, whose memories only extend back 22 years, have rewritten history and believe it is they who created humans. With the help of an exiled human prince and an android distressed by his own limited memory, Kotaro is out to awaken his fellow "sleepers" and teach the world its true history.

    The Flat Earth/Exchange, Vol. 1

    Reviewer's Rating: 
    3
    Pull Quote: 
    People just want to feel a connection with each other, even in a futuristic world where people are all androids. That’s one of the underlying themes of The Flat Earth/Exchange, which goes for an epic feel with a large cast, beautifully-rendered landscapes, multiple perspectives and big emotions. Now if only there had been more of a plot for all those aforementioned things to swirl around, the first volume might have felt like we were being introduced to a science fiction story, not just a well-conceived backdrop.

    The Flat Earth/Exchange Vol 1 by Toshimi Nigoshi Manga Review

    Reviewer's Rating: 
    4
    Pull Quote: 
    Despite being confused during several parts of the story, I thought this was a very interesting concept. Kotaro was placed in suspended animation without his consent or knowledge. During a routine physical, he was given a shot, and the next thing he knows, he’s in a city of ruins. No longer a carefree high school student, he has to find a way to eke out his survival in this bewildering new world he’s found himself in. He has no clue what happened to leave the world in the sorry state that it’s in, and he has no idea what happened to any of his friends or family. That’s enough to keep me reading, even though I kept getting lost in the narrative. Hopefully Toshimi Nigoshi’s storytelling will tighten up in future volumes.

    Flat Earth Exchange Volumes 1 and 2

    Reviewer's Rating: 
    3
    Pull Quote: 
    I think that Flat Earth Exchange would appeal to anyone who likes science fiction with a strong emphasis on human relationships. Anyone who enjoyed Planetes, Jyu-Oh-Sei, or To Terra may want to give Flat Earth Exchange a try. While I might quibble a bit with the pacing and rapid character introductions in the first two volumes, I’m very interested to read the final two volumes of this story to see how it evolved after the author went back and concluded the manga ten years after it was originally published.

    The Flat Earth/Exchange GN 1-2

    Reviewer's Rating: 
    5
    Pull Quote: 
    Raise your hand if you miss the Japanese manga of the last quarter of the 20th century—those bleak, post-apocalyptic tales of convoluted geopolitics and suggestive male bonding that made the careers of the likes of Katsuhiro Otomo (Akira), CLAMP (X)…and, in her own more modest fashion, Toshimi Nigoshi. A little-known creator, Trigun fans may recognize her for her impressive oeuvre of Wolfwood x Vash doujinshi (circle name Shayoukan), but Nigoshi's professional debut actually predates those amateur publications by nearly a decade. Indeed, even by the standards of the industry, The Flat Earth/Exchange has a complicated publication history. First serialized in the early 1990s in Seiji Biblos' short-lived shoujo anthology Patsy, it (along with the magazine) was discontinued after having been compiled into two volumes. The story, at that point still incomplete, fell off the radar until 2002, when new material spanning a final two volumes was commissioned and put out by Enterbrain. Of course, Enterbrain also reprinted the first two volumes originally put out by Seiji Biblos with all-new cover art and designs.